Ballot 5: Mike Mussina
Played 18 years with two teams
Five-time All-Star, six-time Gold Glove winner, won 270 games with career 123 ERA+. 82.7 WAR, 48.6 WAA
Pro argument: Fabulous pitcher for a long time, retired on top of his game.
Con argument: Gut factor, didn't win 300 or strikeout 3,000; Uninspiring base stats like 3.68 ERA. Deserves to be in Hall?: Yes. Will ge…
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial