New Mays HOF (Part II)

Well, I hope you knew that this is a multi-step process.

So first step -- as some of you figured out -- was to put together a Hall of Fame strictly using Wins Above Average along with a few exceptions. The point was to go down WAA until there was a reasonable gap ... and stop there.

For instance, at catcher, it goes like this:

1. Johnny Bench, 46.5 WAA

2. Gary Ca…