125 Comments

Joe, how could you not have "The Kid from Cleveland" (1949) on your list?

Expand full comment

I might have posted this before, but instead of moving the mound or lowering the mound, they should just make the ball a little bigger. Feel like that would immediately reduce spin rates and velocity.

Expand full comment

For your baseball movie list, watch (and add) "Bang the Drum Slowly."

Expand full comment
Jul 21·edited Jul 21

I always wondered if Maddux kept pitching just long enough to have one more win than Clemens. Sadly, he would be four "true wins" short.

Expand full comment

Did Christy Mathewson really have FEWER True Wins, or was that a typo?

Expand full comment

I looked up Blyleven, same...

Expand full comment

Probably harder to write something nice about Marty Schottenheimer’s defensive plan against Elway late in critical games.

Expand full comment

On the subject of true wins, I guess Justin Verlander can halt his quest for 300. By that stat he already has 307. And BTW, Tommy John had 386.

Expand full comment

On the subject of rebranding stats, I’ve always thought OBP should be called “safe %”, and its complement “out %”. Then the same stats for pitchers (with the opposite implications).

Expand full comment

Wouldn’t errors gum that up? The batter is “safe” but it counts against him in OBP.

Expand full comment

Yeah, well that is a mistake by MLB. Either you are on base or you aren't. Counting errors against OBP is dumb

Expand full comment

just wondering if we'll ever see another pitcher join the 300 wins club...

Expand full comment

We will not. Ever.

Expand full comment

How about a cult film shout out for Bleacher Bums. I haven't seen the 1979 version but truly loved the 2002 version. Written by gangster Joey Zasa (or maybe actor Joe Mantegna, a Chicago Kid). Had to rename the team in the movie as the Chicago Bruins to avoid legal trouble but did make reference to a lot of former Chicago Cubs greats.

Expand full comment

The same year they lowered the mound, a lot of things changed, Greg Resor wrote about this fort The Hardball Times in 2014 . https://tht.fangraphs.com/the-height-of-the-hill/

Baseball made the strike zone smaller.

Artificial turf was introduced at another ballpark, which oddly enough to make you squint, had a slightly lower BABIP than grass that season.

A few ballparks moved the fences in.

At anecdotally, the baseball less lively; Jim Hannan called them softer - we'd say deader today.

The same year that Resor post appeared, Baseball prospects did some math stuff with the help of Alan Nathan and found that the mound would have to move back five feet to make a significant difference (https://www.baseballprospectus.com/news/article/23863/overthinking-it-the-other-way-we-could-move-the-mound/). MLB experimented with a one-foot move in the Atlantic League in 2021 and scrapped it halfway through the season.

The thing most likely to increase offense is how they implement ABS because every time baseball's changed the strike zone offense changed; big zone less offense, small zone more offense.

I'll go back to sleep now.

Expand full comment

Thee three best baseball documentaries are the 3 When It Was A Game films.

Expand full comment

No love for “Bingo Long”?

Expand full comment
Jul 20·edited Jul 20

Buck O'Neil hated it, so no chance it'd be on Joe's list.

Expand full comment

I agree, just wondering. Heck, I didn't watch it all the way through.

Expand full comment

As a former debater, I must profess my love of long yellow legal pads!

Wtm and ltm are...what?

Expand full comment

"Wtm" is short for "team wins," and I'll trust you can figure out what "Ltm" means.

Expand full comment

As a smart high school catcher who didn’t hit enough to advance, Bull Durham is my favorite.

The Battered Bastards of Baseball documentary on Netflix is excellent

Joe just go for a walk. Nietschke said all good ideas come while walking. Don’t worry about the heat, this is the coolest summer we will ever have. And even if it’s not yoga, just do some stretching

Can’t just refuse to make pitching more difficult and also lament the lack of offense. Make the strike zone smaller and lower the mound. These have been done before. Any change will require adjustments by pitchers and hitters. Look how great the pitch clock has turned out

Expand full comment

I thought Nietschke said that all good ideas come when trying to tear a quarterback’s head off.

Expand full comment

LT?

Expand full comment

He was just repeating what Butkus said.

Expand full comment

Touche

Expand full comment

Walter Johnson loses wins using “true wins”?

If your ace is willing to come in in relief and picks up a win, I say that’s a truly true win!

Expand full comment